Skip to main content

Republic of Shame by Caelainn Hogan

Caelainn Hogan's Republic of Shame tells us what we all knew. Everyone knew.  Everybody knew and either denied that knowledge or explained away their actions as they took part in it.  Everybody knew but determined that it was a inescapable act of nature, like the rain.  And when we say everyone knew, not only did everyone know women where being unlawfully imprisoned in mother and baby homes and Magdalen Laundries, everyone knew (including the state) that the rates of death in these mother and baby homes far exceeded that of babies and children in any other place in Irish society at the time.  Church, State and public knew they were dying of neglect.  But when circumstances changes and when children could be sold, they stopped dying, then they had a value and could be sold to 'good' families.  As one survivor ruefully observes,  
'When we illegitimate Irish Bastards were suddenly worth more than the cows on the farms, we stopped dying by the thousands.'  

Many of us who grew up in rural Ireland also grew up with septic tanks. A mysterious pit at often at the bottom of the garden, which would occasionally overflow. We were told, effective horror stories about children, who fell in. As I read this book a memory came to me of my father acquiring a dead cat. I don't know where he got it. He explained that he got the dead cat to 'unblock' the septic tank and that the rotting carcass would help rot the impacted shit. Now we learn that, the nuns in Tuam had an overflowing septic tank (there are records of local residents making complaints) and where were the bodies found? Now two and two may not make four, but then again. They claim that the septic tank was no longer in use when the bodies were dumped there. But they do have a history of being thrifty with the truth. Such is the barbarism.  

It is tempting to think of the past as  “a foreign country: they do things differently there,” and there is a large degree of truth to that.  Ireland was a theocracy, where the rule of the church trumped the rule of law.   However what is also true is our collective blindness to our present evils.  In Peter Singer's 'Famine, Affluence and Morality', Singer (convincingly) argues that ordinary people are evil.  We know people are held, on a flimsy legal basis in 'direct provision centres' in Ireland, we know others are drowning in the Mediterranean.  It turns out that we don't need the Catholic Church to be evil, but it did add a flamboyant layer of hypocrisy.  

This is your God fearing Ireland, this is the lost past some still pine for.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Americanah a novel by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie

Americanah is a hymn to the complexity of our emotional lives. It is a novel where many things are said, but these are the things that I heard; 1) there is comfort in cheap chocolate. 2) she shows us how arbitrary brutality pervades our world and some of this is not intentional cruelty; it's just the systemic faceless kind. 3) Harm is a temporal thing, it can happen in an instant and we'll live with it for the rest of our lives. This is obvious in a car crash, but here it is of the emotional kind. Growing into a malignant burden that corrupts the rest of our relationships, and each of us kills the things we love. 4) It's a book about place and identity that rails against those narrow confines of identity. Her characters resist all attempts to be defined or sully themselves in narrow trenches of how to be. 'Ring out false pride in place and blood' 6) Adichie is a woman, who knows her place and that place is among the classics. She has a character joke about the...
Post a Comment
Read more

King Leopold's Ghost by Adam Hochschild

When I started this book, George Floyd was alive.  His name was known only to his loved ones, friends and community.  Now his daughter is without her Daddy, and we know his name.   Imagine a mountain of corpses, George's body is flung somewhere near the top of this pile.  I say near the top since bodies have been added since his murder.  Hochschild's points to the nameless dead, beneath poor George's black body.   Adam Hochschild’s King Leopold’s Ghost needs to be widely read. While it deals with the particular horrors of King Leopold’s reign of terror in the Congo, it makes clear that the butchery characteristic of King Leopold’s reign were features of all European colonies. I first moved from Ireland to England in 1995.  Quickly making English friends, one of the striking observations was how these otherwise well informed and articulate individuals knew next to nothing about Ireland, it’s history and how that history informed it’s current p...
Post a Comment
Read more

How to win friends and influence people. Dale Carnegie. A review and some thoughts.

Dale Carnegie's 1936, 'How to Win Friends and Influence People,' has remaining in continuous print since 1936, selling over 30 million copies.  Something is selling here.  Carnegie has distilled a distinct ideology one deeply ingrained in the Western corporate world’s ethos of mandatory optimism.  While Carnegie's insights are not inherently flawed, their luminescence casts a particularly dense umbra. Carnegie's book aligns with something we know about ourselves, echoing George Orwell's observation: 'The best books tell you what you already know.' The book plays into our innate longing for acceptance and affirmation, fostering a confirmation bias where we gravitate towards ideas that affirm our pre-existing beliefs. Reading Carnegie I could not help thinking of it's antithesis. Arthur Miller's 'Death of a Salesman' (1949) delves into the perilous consequences of such biases.  Willy Loman, epitomises the tragic fallout of conflating charm,...
Post a Comment
Read more