Skip to main content

Home by Eoin O'Brion. A review and some comments




Ireland has a home crisis, construed as a homelessness crisis.  O'Brion shows us what we already know, we inhabitants of this damp rock are pissing our last away in the teeth of squalor and growing out of damp dereliction.  Those who fail to cling on become The Homeless. The reason? Money can rest and gain value in The Land.  


In a delightful affectation, O'Brion's book is presented in Musical Movements, with the introduction being an Overture and the text divided into Three Movements.


O'Brion tells the tale of the radical idealism that founded the nascent state, of how the democratic programme of Dáil Éireann 1919 committed that the interests of private property must be subordinate to the public right and welfare.  It's a story of how solutions are bountiful, solutions created by and placed in our own communities. Yet at each step the lusty embrace between the monied interests and the political class colluded to subvert the public right and welfare.  There is no romanticism here, with O’Brion showing how our leaders have cultivated a long ignoble culture of corruption and cronyism.  


The problems of housing in Ireland are entirely systemic and until the perverse contingencies that perpetuate this system are addressed, nothing will fundamentally change.   Years ago in a pub in Dublin, I remember a friend of a friend, shrugging his shoulders and saying, 'Well, that's just money making money.' People with land, just watch their assets increase in value and that's just how it is.  It hadn't occurred to me that what he was describing was the inflation of a bubble, and bubbles invariably burst.


In 2017 I discovered a newly published book called 'Evicted. Poverty & Profit in the American City' by Matthew Desmond. We were then, as we are now gripped by a housing crisis and our media was presenting it as an Irish issue.  Homelessness isn't a uniquely Irish problem, it happens wherever banks are allowed to attach the other side of their balance sheets to property.


In the Ireland of the recent past, the prevailing doctrine was,  'The Market will do everything'. To go against this principle was like arguing with gravity and seldom did our discourse stray from this truism.  So today, it's seen as obvious as the whiteness of snow, that banks profit from the sale of mortgages and we pay.  


O'Brion argues for an alternative, we need to decouple land from the storage of wealth and view it as a common good. I just wish he did it with a little more pizzazz.  Sadly parts of the book are practically unreadable since they are as dull as the proverbial dishwater. I wanted this book to be better, but more than that I want O'Brion's vision to be realised, if only it were articulated a little better. 

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Half of a Yellow Sun a novel by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie

I was inspired to pick up this book after listening to Chimamanda's 2022 Reith Lectures on the Freedom of Speech. Chimamanda, argues that it feels like freedom of speech is under attack. She names cancel culture, arguments about “wokeness" (I am old enough to remember when we called this political correctness) and the stabbing of Salman Rushdie as producing this atmosphere. Meanwhile, autocrats, populists and an anti-science identity culture have undermined the very notion of an accepted fact-based truth which lives above politics. So how do we calibrate freedom in this context? 'Half of a Yellow Sun,' is as profoundly human, as it is unsettling. The terror and the domestic are cheek by jowl. They live side by side, in the same spaces. I have heard it said that Iris Murdoch's contribution to ethics is that she (along with other feminist philosophers) reframed ethics from the public to the intimate. Similarly, Adichie's narrative highlights that ethics canno...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks by Rebecca Skloot

In her poignant account, Rebecca Skloot sheds light on how the biopharma industry has trampled on bodily autonomy, building their empires on the backs of individuals without their consent. Skloot's book tells the stories of unsung heroes in medical science and exposes the atrocities committed against marginalised communities. Skloot sensitively records the tragic loss of Henrietta Lacks, whose fundamental right to bodily integrity was ignored by society. It is a story of incomprehensible oppression and ignorance, where doctors watched patients die, solely to study the disease prognosis. This was evident in the Tuskegee experiments on untreated syphilis, which took place in the United States between 1932 and 1972. The biopharma industry made incalculable sums of money by taking Henrietta's cells without her knowledge or consent. The ongoing ethical and legal battle raises the question of how to balance scientific advancement with individual freedom. Sadly, commercial interests...
Post a Comment
Read more

Republic of Shame by Caelainn Hogan

Caelainn Hogan's Republic of Shame tells us what we all knew. Everyone knew.  Everybody knew and either denied that knowledge or explained away their actions as they took part in it.  Everybody knew but determined that it was a inescapable act of nature, like the rain.  And when we say everyone knew, not only did everyone know women where being unlawfully imprisoned in mother and baby homes and Magdalen Laundries, everyone knew (including the state) that the rates of death in these mother and baby homes far exceeded that of babies and children in any other place in Irish society at the time.  Church, State and public knew they were dying of neglect.  But when circumstances changes and when children could be sold, they stopped dying, then they had a value and could be sold to 'good' families.  As one survivor ruefully observes,   'When we illegitimate Irish Bastards were suddenly worth more than the cows on the farms, we stopped dying by the thousa...
Post a Comment
Read more