Skip to main content

This Book Will Change Your Mind About Mental Health: A Journey Into the Heartland of Psychiatry by Nathan Filer

'What needs fixing, may not reside within you at all.'


Nathan Filer's book, "This Book Will Change Your Mind About Mental Health," provides a poignant and sobering account of the systemic brutality of the mental health system, contrasted by the kindness and sincere efforts of individuals working within it. The book is a collection of stories from survivors of the mental health system, shedding light on the perplexing paradox of how the sincere efforts of individuals working within a system can culminate into a system that obliterates personal autonomy.

While the book does an excellent job of explaining the how, it neglects to explore the why. Why does the mental health system fail so many people? Why is knowledge about mental illness so misinformed and ignorant? These are critical questions that need to be addressed to truly understand the depth of the problem.

Graham Thornicroft, a professor of community psychiatry at King's College London, asserts that popular knowledge about mental illness is a potent cocktail of profound ignorance and pernicious misinformation. This is a fundamental issue that needs to be addressed, as it perpetuates the stigma and shame surrounding mental ill health.

Nathan explains that what is agreed in mental health is that nothing is agreed. From the terms, to the diagnosis to the treatments, nothing is agreed. We are in a prescientific era in understanding ourselves. For all our technology advances, we barely understand ourselves and people who seek help are at the mercy of this confusion. 

The reality of the pain caused by mental illness is cold and brutal, and the inadequacy of the words used to describe it is . Filer's book provides a much-needed perspective on the mental health system and highlights the urgent need for change. The stories of survivors are a powerful reminder that the system is failing those who need it most and that there is a pressing need for a more compassionate, nuanced, and effective approach to mental health care.

Nathan Filer's book, "This Book Will Change Your Mind About Mental Health," provides a sobering account of the systemic brutality of the mental health system and the urgent need for evidence based change.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Half of a Yellow Sun a novel by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie

I was inspired to pick up this book after listening to Chimamanda's 2022 Reith Lectures on the Freedom of Speech. Chimamanda, argues that it feels like freedom of speech is under attack. She names cancel culture, arguments about “wokeness" (I am old enough to remember when we called this political correctness) and the stabbing of Salman Rushdie as producing this atmosphere. Meanwhile, autocrats, populists and an anti-science identity culture have undermined the very notion of an accepted fact-based truth which lives above politics. So how do we calibrate freedom in this context? 'Half of a Yellow Sun,' is as profoundly human, as it is unsettling. The terror and the domestic are cheek by jowl. They live side by side, in the same spaces. I have heard it said that Iris Murdoch's contribution to ethics is that she (along with other feminist philosophers) reframed ethics from the public to the intimate. Similarly, Adichie's narrative highlights that ethics canno...
Post a Comment
Read more

Republic of Shame by Caelainn Hogan

Caelainn Hogan's Republic of Shame tells us what we all knew. Everyone knew.  Everybody knew and either denied that knowledge or explained away their actions as they took part in it.  Everybody knew but determined that it was a inescapable act of nature, like the rain.  And when we say everyone knew, not only did everyone know women where being unlawfully imprisoned in mother and baby homes and Magdalen Laundries, everyone knew (including the state) that the rates of death in these mother and baby homes far exceeded that of babies and children in any other place in Irish society at the time.  Church, State and public knew they were dying of neglect.  But when circumstances changes and when children could be sold, they stopped dying, then they had a value and could be sold to 'good' families.  As one survivor ruefully observes,   'When we illegitimate Irish Bastards were suddenly worth more than the cows on the farms, we stopped dying by the thousa...
Post a Comment
Read more

American Pastoral, American Berserk

This is a beautiful book, rendered in exquisite prose. If all of life is light and shadow, then American Pastoral shies neither from the light nor the shadow. It shows us unconditional parental love and the callous indifference of our societies at large. It takes a cold hard look at the essential contradictions in American society, and in doing so, is an essential autopsy of the American Dream. The central theme I took from the novel is that it asks what went wrong? How can our loved ones be capable of such terrible things? However, unlike other novels that have asked similar questions, I am thinking of 'We need to talk about Kevin’. by Lionel Shriver. Roth considers the interesting angle of having a familial relationship as almost entirely loving. With parents painstakingly, human, even superhuman. And yet, these horrors still enters their lives. Leaving us to wonder what causes this to go wrong. Roth shows how the political is personal, brushing your teeth is political...
Post a Comment
Read more