Skip to main content

How to win friends and influence people. Dale Carnegie. A review and some thoughts.

Dale Carnegie's 1936, 'How to Win Friends and Influence People,' has remaining in continuous print since 1936, selling over 30 million copies.  Something is selling here.  Carnegie has distilled a distinct ideology one deeply ingrained in the Western corporate world’s ethos of mandatory optimism.  While Carnegie's insights are not inherently flawed, their luminescence casts a particularly dense umbra.



Carnegie's book aligns with something we know about ourselves, echoing George Orwell's observation: 'The best books tell you what you already know.' The book plays into our innate longing for acceptance and affirmation, fostering a confirmation bias where we gravitate towards ideas that affirm our pre-existing beliefs.



Reading Carnegie I could not help thinking of it's antithesis. Arthur Miller's 'Death of a Salesman' (1949) delves into the perilous consequences of such biases.  Willy Loman, epitomises the tragic fallout of conflating charm, popularity and economic success with morality and meaning. Willy's relentless pursuit of superficial acclaim blinds him to the harms he is causing his wife and children and makes his decent into dementia pointedly tragic. 



Both Carnegie and Miller explore the intersection of personal ambition and ethical integrity. While Carnegie may seem to endorse leveraging human frailty for personal gain, a more charitable interpretation suggests an encouragement to empathise with our shared imperfections. Miller, casts a cold eye on the superficial nature of likeability. Miller highlight a particular kind of madness: the conflation of morality with economic success. This phenomenon exposes our vulnerability to manipulation and our propensity to prioritise meaningless superficialities over loved ones and family.



'Death of a Salesman' stands in stark opposition to Carnegie's philosophy. The play’s tragic commentary; 'Be well liked and you'll never want' and Biff's reality confronting tirade 'Pop I am a dine a dozen.  I am not a leader of men and neither are you.  I am one dollar an hour and so are you,' challenges Willy to face, what is so obvious, but continues to be denied.  



Carnegie's book shines a bright light on strategies for personal advancement, it inadvertently casts a shadow on the darker aspects of human nature, such as our susceptibility to superficial validation. 



Barbara Ehrenreich's Smile or Die also inspired these thoughts.

https://www.blinkist.com/en/books/smile-or-die-en

Here is a well written book review, which contrasts sharply with this one https://www.theguardian.com/books/2010/jan/10/smile-or-die-barbara-ehrenreich

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

American Pastoral, American Berserk

This is a beautiful book, rendered in exquisite prose. If all of life is light and shadow, then American Pastoral shies neither from the light nor the shadow. It shows us unconditional parental love and the callous indifference of our societies at large. It takes a cold hard look at the essential contradictions in American society, and in doing so, is an essential autopsy of the American Dream. The central theme I took from the novel is that it asks what went wrong? How can our loved ones be capable of such terrible things? However, unlike other novels that have asked similar questions, I am thinking of 'We need to talk about Kevin’. by Lionel Shriver. Roth considers the interesting angle of having a familial relationship as almost entirely loving. With parents painstakingly, human, even superhuman. And yet, these horrors still enters their lives. Leaving us to wonder what causes this to go wrong. Roth shows how the political is personal, brushing your teeth is political...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks by Rebecca Skloot

In her poignant account, Rebecca Skloot sheds light on how the biopharma industry has trampled on bodily autonomy, building their empires on the backs of individuals without their consent. Skloot's book tells the stories of unsung heroes in medical science and exposes the atrocities committed against marginalised communities. Skloot sensitively records the tragic loss of Henrietta Lacks, whose fundamental right to bodily integrity was ignored by society. It is a story of incomprehensible oppression and ignorance, where doctors watched patients die, solely to study the disease prognosis. This was evident in the Tuskegee experiments on untreated syphilis, which took place in the United States between 1932 and 1972. The biopharma industry made incalculable sums of money by taking Henrietta's cells without her knowledge or consent. The ongoing ethical and legal battle raises the question of how to balance scientific advancement with individual freedom. Sadly, commercial interests...
Post a Comment
Read more